this website gives great directions and even includes step-by-step instructions with PICTURES for those who can't function without visual explanations (like me). And you just can't have a Super Bowl party without wings, people might turn on you.
These are great because 1. spring rolls are always amazing, 2. dipping sauces are always amazing, and 3. because people can eat them with their fingers and you don't have to dirty up a bunch of dishes.
Avant Tarte. They are easy to make and always create quite a commotion. All you do is: Make yellow cupcakes from a mix, let them cool, cut them in half. Make brownies from a mix, let them cool, cut them into circles with a cookie cutter. Layer green, yellow and red icing and build a burger. It's really cute if you finish it off with a colored sandwich toothpick.